Sitting Out the Blue Wave: Turnout, Not a Mass Conversion

Russell Tuf Chairman, Collier County Citizens Values Political Action Committee
The 2026 midterms delivered a national Democratic surge, but the driving force was not a broad rejection of conservative principles. According to post-election analysis by J.L. Partners (based on an Election Day poll and more than 30,000 campaign interviews), roughly two-thirds of the swing came from turnout differences, not voters switching sides.
Of the roughly 15-point movement from the 2024 presidential result to the 2026 House result, about 10 points were attributable to who showed up and who stayed home, and only about 5 points to actual switching. More than one in three Trump 2024 voters (35%) did not vote in November 2026, compared with 22% of Harris 2024 voters. The drop-off was concentrated in key parts of the 2024 coalition:
- 46% of non-college Trump voters stayed home
- 39% of rural Trump voters stayed home
- 44% of Trump voters over age 65 stayed home
Even without any switching, the turnout gap alone would have been enough to cost Republicans the House and Senate. Among those who did switch, half still hold a favorable view of the Republican Party — a group that can be won back.
Florida was different. Amendment 3, which expands the homestead exemption on non-school property taxes, passed with about 62% support statewide. Government spending has outpaced both inflation and population growth for years. When voters were given a direct way to keep more of their own money and push back on rising costs, they took it — Democrats and Republicans alike. That local result underscores a durable preference for fiscal restraint and affordability.
In Collier County the national pattern did not fully materialize, but the new congressional map produced one clear change: strong Republican areas including Marco Island and East Naples are now represented in Congress by Democrat Pia Dandiya of Palm Beach County. Whether that representation prioritizes the distinct needs of Southwest Florida remains to be seen.
What this means for our values. The results do not show that the principles that have defined Collier County and Florida have suddenly lost support. Limited government, fiscal responsibility, individual liberty, and equal opportunity are not partisan slogans — they are practical safeguards. Political power does not become safer simply because “our” candidates hold the levers. The Founders repeatedly stressed both the necessity of virtue and the reality of human fallibility; that is why they designed a system of limited, checked authority rather than open-ended discretion.
Over the coming months, CCCVPAC will focus on restating those enduring values in clear terms — values that continue to resonate with most people across party lines. We will also apply them practically by developing candidate questionnaires, vetting candidates, and issuing endorsements in local races, beginning with the Naples City Council special election on February 2, 2027.




Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!